Why Do We Get Grades in School?
- Articles, Blog

Why Do We Get Grades in School?

We all remember the dreaded end of semester
Armageddon known as “report card day.” But why do we get letter grades in school
at all? So getting grades is a big part of the way
we view education with A’s equaling success while F’s represent the dreaded failure. Students are taught early on that to get ahead
in life, and be smart and successful, the best foundation is getting perfect report
cards in school. Grades can help us get into advanced courses
and competitive colleges, and certain exams can grant us licenses to practice different
trades and professions. But outside of the nagging question about
why we skipped over the E grade, have you ever wondered: When were the first grades
given and why? Well if you want to blame someone, it appears
that the first grades date back to Yale president Ezra Stiles in 1785. He wrote in his diary that there were 58 students
present at his examination and that their grades were “Twenty Optimi, sixteen second
Optimi, 12 Inferiores (Boni), ten Pejores.” These are usually noted as the first college
grades ever assigned. In Yale’s 1813-1839 “Record of Examinations”
students’ averages were noted in the book by the Senior Tutor of the Class on a scale
of 4, which may be responsible for the 4.0 scale commonly used today. In 1817 the faculty reports from William and
Mary College groups students into 4 categories “No 1 the first in their respective classes,
No 2 Orderly, correct, and attentive, No. 3 They have made very little improvement,
No. 4 They have learnt little or nothing.” Ouch. That’s a major teacher burn. But the four point scale wasn’t really standardized
throughout the 19th century. Harvard tried a 100 point scale and a 20 point
scale. Yale later tried a 9 point scale. So until 1850 it was normal for grades to
vary in terms of number systems, and weight. In US colleges professors used descriptive
adjectives to assign value rather than relying on the numbers alone. But by 1883 there is a report on a Harvard
professor giving a student a “B” grade, which is when letters got incorporated into
the act. In 1886 Harvard Faculty Records show that
professors began grouping students into 5 classes based on performance. Similar 5 point systems spread to places like
Yale, and Mount Holyoke, the latter of which adopted the first letter grade system in 1897. But a failing grade was marked as an “E”
and not an “F”. Over time the E was dropped and the standard
system across US colleges became 5 points all represented by letters A, through D, and
F. But the meanings of grades and the systems for recording them often shifted in the late
nineteenth and early 20th centuries Ok so we’ve established that if we want
somewhere to point the finger of blame for why we received stressful grades in school,
and why a less than stellar score on a 6th grade pop quiz gave me heart palpitations,
we can start with a bunch of 19th century college professors. But the more important questions is: why are
we still getting grades in school today? Those guys are dead. So they’re useful for determining class
ranking, they help teachers group students into categories, and they can also be instrumental
in whether or not you can enter into certain jobs. But because I’m sure a lot of us are still
suffering from post report card induced stress, we have to ask the most pressing questions:
do grades really matter? And are they actually effective tools for
helping students learn? Well the answer to the first question “do
grades really matter” is kind of complex and has to be broken down a bit to get to
the heart of it. Because it seems that the importance of your
grades depends on the path you decide to take. Although we’re taught that grades are the
strongest predictor of success in life, this isn’t uniformly true. The issue with grades is that they consider
averages, which gives you the most usual outcome but not the full picture. An average doesn’t consider the outliers,
but rather the collective information from a certain group. History is actually filled with successful
people who didn’t finish college or even high school: Magic Johnson, Anna Wintour,
Steve Jobs, Richard Branson, and Oprah Winfrey to name a few, and none of these people did
too shabbily in the life success department. Also having perfect grades in high school
doesn’t always predict future game changers. Karen Arnold of Boston University conducted
a study in which she followed 81 high school valedictorians and salutatorians. She found that the majority of them continued
being successful at school later in life. 95% earned college degrees with an average
GPA of 3.6, 60% went to graduate school, 90% are in professional jobs, and 40% are in the
highest tiers of those jobs. This is because a high GPA reflects skills
like being prompt, working really hard, following directions and being well rounded. All important skills for high level careers. But Arnold found that although most of her
former high school valedictorians and salutatorians were “strong occupational achievers” none
had entered into roles she would consider “visionary” because the grades we receive
in school are designed to reward conformity and following the rules, rather than creative
thinking or specialization. For example if you’re really great at history
(shout out to our audience members) but you still want to be ranked number 1, you eventually
will have to put that history textbook on the back burner to study other subjects and
earn the coveted “A” in every field. Having a high GPA is usually indicative of
being a generalist, not a specialist. Arnold posits that most people who become
ground breakers are actually rewarded for creative thinking, a unique specialization,
and a focus on an intellectual passion, things that don’t always get rewarded with grades. As a result a lot of people who become successful
later in life often struggle in school. But a 2002 study at the University of Michigan
still found that 80 percent of students based their self-worth on how well they were doing
in school and students with lower grades reported having lower self-esteem and health. So that brings us to the next question: do
grades really help students learn? Although grades have long been considered
the standard approach in education, some experts are turning away from letter based systems. One of the biggest critics of the fixation
on grades in schools is education expert Alfie Kohn. Kohn notes:
“The research quite clearly shows that kids who are graded – and have been encouraged
to try to improve their grades – tend to lose interest in the learning itself, avoid
challenging tasks whenever possible (in order to maximize the chance of getting an A), and
think less deeply than kids who aren’t graded…That’s why the best teachers and schools replace
grades (and grade-like reports) with narrative reports – qualitative accounts of student
performance – or, better yet, conferences with students and parents.” Teachers also report that grading is becoming
increasingly stressful, as grade inflation puts added pressure on them to deliver the
grades that students want and parents expect. Some educators are moving away from letter
and number based grading to standards based grading. In 2013 Kentucky implemented a system where
students received 2 report cards: one with the traditional letter grades, and another
with a individualized breakdown of what students had learned and the students’ progress in
school. Virginia’s Fairfax County implemented a
similar process in their elementary schools in the 2012-2013 school year. Parents reported finding the new system initially
confusing, but ultimately more helpful in assessing their child’s growth and progress
in school. And classrooms around the world, including
public schools, private schools, and educational initiatives funded by nonprofits, are looking
to incorporate new methods in the classroom that place less emphasis on memorization and
focus more on innovation and how students can retain new knowledge. So even though grades are the oldest way of
doing things, they may not be the best for measuring students’ long term success. So how does this all add up? It seems grades do have some weight in determining
student outcomes because we’ve based so many systems around it, but this can vary
a lot based on the individual. While grades are extremely important in certain
trajectories, like going to college, attending graduate school, or entering into certain
professions, they ultimately aren’t the only determining factor of success. And although we’ve accepted them as the
marker of a good student, a perfect GPA doesn’t always represent things like creativity, ingenuity,
and intellectual passions. Which is why more school systems and educators
are looking for ways to measure student progress outside of letters and percentages. So what do you think? Have any other theories about how grades became
so entrenched in our education system? Drop all your comments and questions down
below (we swear we won’t ask you to share your old report cards) and we’ll see you
next week!

About James Carlton

Read All Posts By James Carlton

100 thoughts on “Why Do We Get Grades in School?

  1. AGAIN, a video that doesn’t answer the question asked by the title. A more accurate title would be: “WHEN, did we start getting letter grades in school?” You never addressed WHY letters or WHY we skip E. I expect more from PBS. If you don’t find an interesting story in researching your topic, maybe pick a different topic instead of being misleading with a click-bait title.

  2. It might just be me, but after 5:38 it seems like the music became much louder and more intrusive.
    Like the presenter was struggling to be heard over it.

  3. It is good to hear that institutes are finally trying something different, the current grading system is a bit like telling a patient "well, you sick." instead of suggesting what is actually the wrong and/or what to do about it.

  4. I watched my school slowly fall from teaching to standardized testing within 4 years. At first, it felts freer. We did more projects rather than tests and it felt like teachers had more control over what they wanted to teach. Year two, it got more restrained. Things weren't as free and tests increased. There was a noticeable shift with the teachers' happiness. The third year, everything went sour. All of my teachers were complaining daily about activities they loved doing with their students that they were forced to replace with tests. This is the year we almost got a standardized test for every single class in the high school. It was very bad and we barely skirted out of it. Year four just felt empty.

    You could tell that the teachers didn't like to teach anymore. Even the good teachers were overstressed trying to figure out how to best teach with this unceasing testing curriculum. There was a drop in the drive for the students' work ethic. I was one of those students. While I still graduated honors, I lost my passion for learning in school. I would go to school, chug down information, regurgitate it a few days later during the quiz/test, then promptly forget it.

    It's time for a change. For our future's sakes.

  5. Fourth grade was the first year we got letter grades. On the first day of school, the teacher explained to us what A, B, C, D, and F meant. I then raised my hand and asked "How come there ain't no 'E'?"

  6. Ok, but the people you mentioned that didn't finish high school or college are part of a very small group of people, and if you look at their lives, attended college informally, and always did things to learn more (basically teaching themselves).

  7. New Zealand switched to NCEA years ago, a system where students would get descriptions such as achieved, rather than a percentage grade. It meant their overall performance wasn't so dependant on exams, but some students found they weren't as well prepared to the exam culture in university as a result.

  8. Did the "background" music really have so load (and horrible)? To have the presenter shout over the music is not helpful in bringing the message across.

  9. In my school we have 1- 1 1+ 2- 2 2+ 3- 3 3+ 4- 4 4+ 1- being you failed and you will never have a good life witch is not true and 4+ being you are great and you will have a good life witch may not be true it's sad how people think a number or a letter can ruin or make your life great

  10. A+: Party!
    A: Could do better
    B: Long lecture (from mom)
    C: Don't bother coming back home. Death's literally in front of you.
    D: Might have to burn your paper
    E/F: You can move out now…

  11. I always made good grades, but I knew that I was working hard for a good grade on the next test or assignment, not to actually learn the information

  12. Your grade isn't a tool for helping you your grade is meant to determine how well you understood the material it's a measure of sufficiency not a tool for teaching you by the time you get a grade all the teaching has been done while it is true that some peekers can be bad teachersremoving the grading system doesn't stop that if a majority of students is failing it's likely the teacher's fault where the admission officers fault for allowing idiots into the class

  13. Percentages/grades make sense in most subjects, like math, all sciences, grammar, buisness, trades, and sometimes other things. But you should not be given a percentage for your essay on the influences on early Japanese society, for example. My point is, if it is either right or wrong, it should be graded. If it is highly subjective, then it should be given something else.

  14. School grades have implemented such a toxic mindset for me. I have so much anxiety and constantly need to get high marks to feel valued and still don't feel like it's enough. I have NO talents and NO idea what skills I'm capable of. In the last few months of my senior year I feel like I've learnt nothing and have become a broken demotivated member of society, completely represented by a letter grade. Now that's bullshit.

  15. Wait why is Marie Curie here?? She graduated top of her class. No. 1 for her Physics degree, and No. 2
    for her Chemistry degree.

  16. I wish grades were measured as a general scale, like the standard based grading system. I don’t want my knowledge to be measured in the same way we measure meat.

  17. Me
    I think the whole school system needs a total make over. It was established during the time when factory jobs were most common, right? Today, you'd hardly find one of those.

  18. grades are awesone if done fairly. Especially if the teacher can tell you which areas you got right/wrong/partial credit. But I guess since some people might feel bad – why bother grading? How do numbers/letters make you feel? WHat does a plus sign smell like? Is the number 7 odd, or just different? and to those with anxiety/similar issues – I empathize – but grading is not the problem. It's a much deeper issue for which you should consider professional help (honestly, no offence intended).

  19. My district is moving toward standards-based grading and it doesn’t do good things for above average students in particular

  20. I hope public high schools are able to legally allow students to choose their core classes to suit their interests while still meeting the credit requirements to graduate, while keeping the letter system. When you’re taking a course you actually enjoy, you’re more likely to try to do well as what you’re interested in can apply to the coursework. Electives should also require the same amount of credit as core classes in order to fill in the gaps.

    However, the letter system is more concrete as teachers can follow a guideline rather than do individualized reports because the criteria to receive the equivalent of a letter grade would have to be universal amongst the entire county, province, et certera in order to avoid unfairness and bias among teachers.

    Of course, this proposal is flexible and it probably isn’t the best method to grade a student’s abilities.

  21. Even though I get good grades, I still don’t know what I am doing sometimes in my courses. I go to an American high school, and I see trends like cramming, which loses long-term memorization, for tests all the time. If you know what you’re doing, it’s easy in some high schools to get all As/maybe a few Bs while not trying (I try to stray from doing this). Some students tend to not be great test takers because of test anxiety, and this can limit your chance of getting a good grade. This is because tests generally make up 40-50% of your overall semester grade. There are many other ways to evaluate student performance because grades generally don’t tell the whole story.

  22. I'm currently a 7th grader, and my elementary and middle schools both used numbers for our grading system.
    It's from a scale of 1-4, 1 being the lowest and 4 being the highest.

    1 – Below Grade Level
    2 – Near Grade Level
    3 – Proficient
    4 – Advanced

    To get a 3, you just need to do the bare minimum/what's required. To get a 4, you have to do what's required and then think harder to answer a more challenging question, come up with ideas that connect to the world on a larger scale, or put in extra effort.

  23. So i spend like 18 years in schools,got Lot of A's


    I dont know How i buy a house,make a credit card,or pay bills and taxes(Fake Story)

  24. I have a 1.8gpa …my only choice was to go to real estate and invest in stocks. Do not regret it one bit 🙂

  25. Most of you might be so worried because of your bad school grades. You don’t need to worry anymore, just contact Vladimir.hacks on Instagram asap, he would help you change it to what you want it to be.

  26. I have used Cyberspaceintelligence quite a numberof times and he has never disappointed me..He does all types of mobile hack;get unrestricted and unnoticeable access

    to your partner/spouse/anybodies facebook account,email,watsapp,textmessages.He also makes changes in any database/website such as your college/university

    grades..Getting the job done is as simple as sending an email or text ([email protected]) or CYBERSPACEINTELLIGENCE on instagram Tell him i reffered

    you.He will help you

  27. Now that I've been out of school awhile….. i feel like alot of grades were based on the teacher's opinion more so than it being right sometimes. More so with english and writing parts in regular/standardized tests.

  28. If the purpose of school is to train you for the working world, I wonder why education isn't more vocational overall and so general. It doesn't make sense to me. You don't get grades at work but you do get evaluations. That's probably why a number of colleges and primary and secondary schools are getting rid of letter grades.

  29. In my school we have the usual report cards with our grades from 0-10 and then an extra paper with our capacities from initial to advanced.
    Also, the person who managed to get a perfect grade for college in Spain was actually a kid who wanted to study drama.

  30. I didn't believe university grades can be hacked and upgrade till I benefited from this great genius. I Read some reviews about cyber tech work then I hired them to change my grade, trust me I was amazed by their hacking skills that's why I decided to publish them. You should also patronize them; they are really fast, affordable and competent. contact at [email protected]

  31. Thanks so much to cyber tech for helping me hack into my School Database to change all my poor grades from F"s and D"s to A"s and B"s, when its seems i had given up that i would not be graduating when am supposed to along with my friends, cyber tech the database expert did it, first they removed the hold, attendance, boost my GPA, you have doubts check out the reviews below of anyone that ever contacted him after seeing this review. If you are also interested in any sort of hack job, you can thank me later. Contact via email at [email protected]

  32. with the help of my sister who introduce me to a hacker, i'm able to pass out of school with flying color. i couldn't thank enough, i just need to shout him for what he has done for. he did rescue my academic career from nothing to the best. meet him on what'sapp. (+1 323 248-1347)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *