The battle over for-profit colleges, explained
- Articles, Blog

The battle over for-profit colleges, explained

In recent years, a number of for-profit colleges have closed across the US. “For-profit college closed its remaining 28 campuses affecting 16,000 students.” “Their campuses were closed. And we’re talking all of them for good.” “Some of the nation’s largest for profit colleges are seeing steep declines in enrollment.” The Obama administration led a crackdown after years of shady recruiting tactics, predatory lending, and sub-par academics. But in days after the 2016 election, the stock prices of for-profit education companies spiked. Donald Trump hasn’t laid out his policies on for-profit colleges, “I’m a tremendous believer in education.” but he previously owned a for-profit school, Trump University. And with a Republican Congress that also opposes strict government regulations, these companies may see their fortunes changing. For-profit colleges have been around since 1854. They mostly provided short-term certificate programs for specific occupations. But their growth accelerated sharply in the last 2 decades. The federal government was expanding student aid and the poor job market during the Great Recession pushed more people into college. For-profit schools added more and more 2-year and 4-year degree programs. Compared to other colleges, for-profit institutions attract more low-income people, veterans, and other non traditional students. Also known as proprietary colleges, for-profit institutions are operated by private, profit-seeking businesses — which means earnings get passed on to owners or shareholders. That sets them apart from most universities and colleges, which are non-profits. Those state schools, community colleges, and private nonprofits are funded by a bunch of different sources in addition to tuition, like donations, investment income, or government subsidies. But for-profit schools rely almost entirely on tuition and fees paid with federal student aid money. So they have a strong incentive to recruit more students and set them up with large financial aid packages, or tap into veterans’ military benefits. That means they spend a lot of money on marketing and recruiting, promoting convenient locations, specialized courses, and flexible class scheduling. You’ve probably seen their ads on TV or heard them on the radio. “You’re ready for Strayer University.” “Build your personal education plan at You can see how aggressive their recruiters are–
I recently filled out a request for information through the University of Phoenix’s website. And within 48 hours I received 1 email, 2 texts, and 8 phone calls. An undercover investigation of 15 for-profit colleges in 2010, found that all of them made deceptive statements while recruiting. They exaggerated their employment and graduation outcomes, misrepresented their costs, and in some cases, actually encouraged students to lie on their financial aid forms. “You’re not supporting anyone else? Or anything?” “No I’m not.” “So now if we go back and say ok you make $30,000 and you’re claiming a couple of people…I’ll make the corrections according to what you’re telling me.” “Is there a reason why you put this amount in for cash?” “I got an inheritance last year…” “They don’t need to know how much cash you have, that’s why you do the tax return…just to fyi they don’t need to know your cash.” When students finally enroll, they’re presented with loan packages to cover tuition costs. But they’re often not set up to succeed and pay back those loans. The combination of higher tuition, a poorer student population, and a lack of counseling on financial aid and career goals has meant that many students end up worse off than if they hadn’t enrolled at all. By 2014 for-profit colleges accounted for just 11% of the higher education population, but 44% of federal student loan defaults. Back in 2000, only one for-profit college was among the 25 colleges with the most student debt. In 2014, more than half of that list was for-profit schools. And many of the students saddled with debt didn’t even graduate. Of the students who began a 4-year degree program in 2008 — only 27% of those in for-profit schools had graduated 6 years later…. Compared to 65% at private nonprofit colleges and 58 percent at public colleges. The Obama administration responded with several new regulations on the industry. If you look through for-profit college web sites today, there’s a section labeled disclosures that helps students compare schools. The “gainful employment” regulation also says some programs can be disqualified from federal student aid if their students end up with a debt-to-earnings ratio that’s too high. With tighter regulations and lower enrollments due to the improving economy, many for-profit campuses closed. Now the future of those regulations is uncertain. For-profit colleges continue to have a role to play in higher education. They’re often more accessible to students who have families or have to work full-time. Many of them enroll students who couldn’t get into traditional schools. And they provide an alternative to crowded and underfunded community colleges. But their incentives can cut against the well-being of their own students, who know that college doesn’t last forever and hope that their student debt won’t either. If you defaulted on your federal student loans or need help with repayment, visit Links to repayment plans, what to do if you defaulted, and eligibility for student loan discharge are in the description box below.

About James Carlton

Read All Posts By James Carlton

21 thoughts on “The battle over for-profit colleges, explained

  1. Don't you think it's ironic that there are ads for for profit colleges before these videos. I understand vox needs to funds these videos but let's just think about the irony in the dicotomy in the two messages being sent

  2. I got caught up with itt tech fraud but almost save up enough money to cover it up and do it diy engineer school now

  3. There's an interesting satire named "Bad Biz: Your Guide to Starting a For-Profit College" by Corin Devaso. It's on Amazon. You learn a lot about how the for-profit colleges think and operate…and take your tax dollars.

  4. Aren't all universities in America for profit? Aren't hospitals the same? Education and Healthcare should be universally free.

  5. Anyone who decides to attend a for-profit college should have a realistic view. The education is comparable to any state and even profit colleges. However, it is not going to guarantee a career because NO COLLEGE can. It’s all in what a person does with the education. I think for-profit colleges are better for those over 25 years old and older who have a steady job who is looking to possibly advance in their careers. The schedules are flexible and cater to working adults.

  6. The tuition issues exist at ALL colleges. Most Americans have college debt and most did not attend for-profit colleges. College is expensive no matter where a person attends, unless you get a full scholarship or great financial aide.

  7. They claimed excellent job placement. One time I asked an instructor working in one of these for profit schools (TCI Technical Career Institutes), and he said that technically, once someone graduates from his school, and the graduate is arranged to work at McDonald's flipping burgers, technically that is Job Placement. By the way, TCI is no more. Good thing.

  8. What we need to accept is that if we don't consider that college may not be feasible, an investment, that these places are obviously scams. They catered to students that really do not want to go to school. Its like a gym that doesn't encourage hard workouts, and offers free pizza and bagels on Fridays.

  9. So trump tried his hand at a university and it failed, so what? How many businesses do you own that make money and employ people with benefits, go ahead I’ll wait.
    Also under the Obama administration hundreds of thousands were laid off or let go with little to no hours to survive on, we are still paying the price for Obama’s reckless spending, he ran up the national debt more than every other president combined. Yet, being the liberal you are, you won’t talk about that, will you?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *